The outrageous White House report on Iraq. »
Posted by: deathray 1 year, 1 month ago213 Comments Report this Story
The White House report released today, on how far Iraq has progressed toward 18 political and military benchmarks, is a sham.
Read Full Story at slate.com
Join the Discussion 
+ Add Comment
Comments So Far: 213
-

deathray1 year, 1 month ago
"According to the report, which was required by Congress, progress has been "satisfactory" on eight of the benchmarks, "unsatisfactory" on another eight, and mixed on two. At his press conference this morning, President Bush, seeing the glass half full, pronounced the report "a cause for optimism"â;;and for staying on course."
Staying in course for what, exactly?
Reply-

dandt16121 year, 1 month ago
OIL. If you notice that everytime Bush or one of his gang members speak they bring up the oil law. You didn't hear about it to often until recently. I believe that Bush & gang are staying the course because of the oil law and the goodies that it will bring. Period.
Reply-

scriblerus11 year, 1 month ago
You must also include war-profits other than oil. Every time a Hummer gets blown up, we taxpayers have to buy another one, and a company in the military industrial complex makes money. Also, as long as the war continues, we taxpayers get to buy more Coca Cola at $100 per case. When a soldier is on patrol in 120 degree heat in full body armor, he drinks a helluva lot of Coke. I don't think I need to list all the thousands of goods and services we taxpayers supply to this effort for you to get the picture about war-profits.
Reply -

MajJohn1 year, 1 month ago
AMAZING, you're off topic by remark 2. And you have all the lemmings following you. Why no comment on whether or not significant progress has been made toward meeting bench marks by September? It appears the President may be overly optimistic, but I'm reserving judgment until September.. The rest of you can rant and rave if you want about the rich and poor and profiteering. If you think about it, this type of thing happens any any war if you invest your resources toward the war effort.
Reply
-
-

gamahuche1 year, 1 month ago
I listened to Bush talking on the radio about this. He was 100%unconvincing, basically sounded like one of those wind-up kids stuffed toys.
He's not charisma personified at the best of times but this was so pitiful that one had to experience some kind of pity for the man.
As many people have commented the 8/18 was hardly a passing mark and with all the caveats figured in and as the Slate story clearly laid out that the [usually partial] "successes" - all in the less important categories - were also defined extremely "creatively". Any halfway competent lawyer would rip this "evidence" into little pieces.
How much longer will this black comedy continue and however will someone find a way to draw the curtain on it? And how long will the nation need to heal and recover?
Reply -

deathray1 year, 1 month ago
Ultimately, this report, providing the DC establishment and the punditocracy with something to debate, is strictly an obfuscation, designed to blur the lines between success and failure, to give the Administration more time.
Reply -

UBCONFUSE1 year, 1 month ago
Deathray-
You obviously tune out the words when Bush speaks. Bush has turned the corner on Iraq. This report is exactly the cover Bush needs to start the pull out. The next report will also be bad as The Shiia majority are not going to vote to share oil equally. The other issues involve bringing former Bathist managers back to run the infrastructure of Iraq. This is not going to happen, but needs to. Then you have the Sadr issue and the Shiia refuse to let the US kill this freak of Islam.
Currently, the US is getting help from the Sunni and Kurdish tribes with great success. The Shiia are the problem and Saddam had the exact same problems with them.
I still say Bush will pull back to Kuwait or to remote border areas and run interdiction operation to slow down Iran, Syria and the Saudi extremist pouring across the borders. The US will remain close by but out of sight. However, watch out if Hillary or Obama is elected as Iran will likely attack US troops to test waters.
Reply-

deathray1 year, 1 month ago
LOL, UB, I never claimed that the President wasn't feeling the pressure, or that he wasn't looking for a way out; I merely claim that the interim report is being used as a device to extend the debate while Republicans attempt to find a way out of Iraq. and somehow save the party from self immolation. It's a delaying tactic.
I think the President is looking for something he can use to adopt the Baker Hamilton/ISG recommendations and still save face, something the Democrats have been advocating for some time.
One can only hope that Prsident Bush is coming to see the errors in the prosecution of this war. In the meantime, his delaying tactics are getting US troopers killed and injured, and only demonstrating tactical, and not strategic, successes.
I agree that we need to be mindful of Iran.
Reply
-
-
catstevensComment removed: User banned.1 Reply
-
-

kriicket1 year, 1 month ago
You know, we have so many people who are conflicted on what they think about the war....and the media doesn't help any...there are conflicting reports on who wants us to stay and who wants us to go. We hear stories of soldiers who have become friends with some of the Iraqi people...and those who want us to stay...then we have reports that they want us to leave. I think some of the Iraqi people are divided about this war as much as we are.
Reply-

lvrofwolves1 year, 1 month ago
Just killed me last night when I heard Bush say 'the same people who attacked us on 9/11 are the same people we are fighting in Iraq today'. then a minute later, 'of course those who attacked us are dead'.
I don't know...Bush seems to be having some problems getting his thoughts/stories straight lately, and the way he stays on course? I call it stubborness. The way he thinks we can and are winning the war, sounds like the insane ideas that Hitler had. He wanted to stay the course no matter the cost, even when it was blatantly evident he was losing. Pure delusional stubborness.
I'd really love to see some real facts that we have made any progress, any at all. Seems to me we are worse off now plus billions in debt and more importantly almost 4,000 Americans killed in war, countless injured. Are we safer now???? noooooooooo and who really do we need more protection from exactly? terrorists? or our Government right now?
Reply
-

